Countywide

State legislation in the works to limit Dillon Rule in Va., grant localities more power

A coalition of advocacy groups plans to press the Virginia General Assembly in 2027 to hand over some of its powers to local governments.

“The people closest to the problem are closest to the solution,” said Maria Robalino, executive director of the Virginia Home Rule Project, during a briefing yesterday (Nov. 16) on the organization’s plans for the upcoming session.

Its motto for the effort is “Local Voices, Local Choices,” Robalino said.

“Virginia is not one-size-fits-all,” she said.

Since the 19th century, political power in Virginia has been concentrated at the state level, with localities largely unable to act absent explicit authority provided in the Virginia Constitution or state law.

That approach to governance is “a barrier between communities and the solutions they need,” said Boaz Young-El, the statewide campaigns director for the New Virginia Majority advocacy group, one of the organizations supporting the Virginia Home Rule Coalition’s efforts.

People “should have a government that can respond” to local needs, Young-El said.

Del. Fernando “Marty” Martinez, D-29 (screenshot via Virginia Home Rule Project)

Patroning a bill to move some powers to the local level will be Del. Fernando “Marty” Martinez (D-29), who represents part of Loudoun County.

As a two-decade member of the Leesburg Town Council, Martinez said he saw first-hand “how frustrating it is” to have to go to Richmond for authority on multiple issues. As a result, good ideas were “being set aside before they can even be tried.”

Martinez and other organizers did not delve into specifics of their proposal, which is currently being evaluated by the General Assembly’s Division of Legislative Services. The full measure will be publicly released once it clears that procedural step.

Pressed on the likelihood of the bill’s passage, Martinez — who serves on the House Committee on Counties, Cities and Towns — said he was trying to be realistic.

“I’m not going to say it’s going to be easy,” he said. “I’m doing everything I can. I’m not carrying it to fail; I’m carrying it to pass.”

Those touting the measure are currently seeking potential patrons in the Virginia Senate and have been holding “positive conversations” with the governor’s office, Virginia Municipal League and Virginia Association of Counties, according to Robalino.

The bill won’t seek to give localities unimpeded power to set their own policies, but it aims to provide a better balance than currently exists, she said.

“The General Assembly is supreme, the state constitution is supreme, state law remains supreme,” Robalino said.

Christian Martinez Lemus, representing the We Are CASA immigrant and civil rights advocacy group, said advocates for a variety of issues often run into a brick wall when talking to members of local governing bodies.

“They’re met with the same frustrating answer: ‘Our hands are just tied,'” he said.

Virginia Home Rule Project director Maria Robalino (screenshot via Virginia Home Rule Project)

Giving local governments a larger degree of autonomy “unlocks the door” to innovation, Martinez Lemus said.

“Our local leaders know our neighborhoods,” he said.

The Fairfax County Board of Supervisors has long pressed for targeted increases in local authority on issues from taxes to trash collection, while also trying to protect the powers it does have and pushing for more state funding. But like others, county leaders may have to wait for the home rule bill’s actual language to determine what position, if any, to take on it.

The supervisors’ legislative committee in early December is set to resume a series of meetings focused on the 2027 General Assembly session. The county government each year issues its own lengthy list of policy priorities, which are used to guide advocacy efforts in Richmond.

Virginia is one of the few remaining “Dillon Rule” states across the U.S. The term takes its name from John Forrest Dillon (1831-1914), who as a federal judge in the 1880s posited that local governments have no inherent powers and must rely on those delegated from their state government.

Many other states — so-called “home-rule” jurisdictions — have delegated significant authority to local governments.

“Virginia is an outlier. Most states provide some form of home rule,” said Carmen Daugherty, executive director of the Advancement Project, who spoke at the Nov. 16 briefing.

Efforts to loosen Dillon Rule restrictions in the commonwealth have yielded some success in recent decades. Across the region, organizations are gearing up again to tackle the issue.

Earlier this month, delegates to the Arlington County Civic Federation voted unanimously to endorse a package calling on the General Assembly to give localities more autonomy on issues ranging from tree preservation to regulation of electric mobility devices.

Seeking more local autonomy on a variety of issues is a staple of the organization’s annual legislative wish list.

“In general, our opinion has been to expand the authority of Arlington to do things we think Arlington should want to do,” said Dave Shutz, who co-chairs the Civic Federation legislative committee with Francine Friedman.

The 2027 General Assembly session will convene on Jan. 13 for what is expected to be a 45-day session. In November 2027, all 40 Senate and 100 House of Delegates seats will be on the ballot.

About the Author

  • Scott McCaffrey

    A Northern Virginia native, Scott McCaffrey has four decades of reporting, editing and newsroom experience in the local area plus Florida, South Carolina and the eastern panhandle of West Virginia. He spent 26 years as editor of the Sun Gazette newspaper chain. For Local News Now, he covers government and civic issues in Arlington, Fairfax County and Falls Church.